Scottish independence: The choices in a nutshell


MUCH has been said and written about the break up of the United Kingdom and what it would mean for the people of Scotland and the rest of these islands.

Some have claimed that a fully independent Scotland would be landed with a debt-ridden economy and others have argued over the timing of a referendum and what the question on the ballot paper should be.

Michael Gove (left) with David Wooding

But nobody has brought the key issues into sharper focus than Education Secretary Michael Gove.

In a few off-the-cuff words, he summed up the choices facing voters north of the border. He accused SNP leader Alex Salmond of ducking the big question about independence – and lacking the nerve to call a referendum on full independence.

Scots-born Mr Gove’s unrehearsed words on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme this morning get straight to the point and are worth reading in full.

He said: “We need to have a decisive yes or no question on whether or not the people of Scotland want to be independent or not.

“Alex Salmond has been trying to play a tactical game here in order to strengthen the political position of his party. By doing so, he has avoided and dodged so far some fundamental questions.

“Do the people of Scotland want to have the same level of welfare benefits as the rest of the United Kingdom? Do they want to be part of the same nation that has the British Broadcasting Corporation and a National Health Service?

“Do they want the Royal Navy and the British Army to remain institutions that embody patriotic feeling and sentiment or do they want to sunder and separate them?

“Do they want you and I to be forced to choose between being British and Scottish, to have a narrow, exclusive, ethnic nationalist identity as our only choice or do they believe that we should be plural, multi-cultural, modern and 21st century?

“These are big questions that Alex Salmond has dodged. He shouldn’t have to dodge them for ever.”

One comment on “Scottish independence: The choices in a nutshell

  1. neilmarr says:

    As a fierce, Scot, Dave, I moved back to the country (well, the Daily Record, anyway) to help (privately) campaign for independence in the first referendum back in the late seventies. We needed a two-thirds majority and fell short. Something over 58% in favour, as I recall. I’m now much older and a tad wiser — thoroughly ‘European’ in attitude — and strongly believe the notion of Scottish independence to be pointless, pretentiously potty and potentially disastrous. Gove puts it well in mere page lead size. Thanks, ol’ pal. Neil

    PS: My late old man, who died in Germany in 1980 after living the last thirty years of his life outside Scotland, would have disowned me for typing what I just did. He said he’d do *anything* for the Auld Country … apart from live there as long as it was a mere and minor part of the United Kingdom. N

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s